TOW is Fantasy, the next evolution of it. Its rules are fundamentally based on previous editions of the Warhammer Fantasy ruleset, the models it uses are the same as those released for previous editions of Fantasy, and the world it refers to is exactly the same, just a few centuries in the past. Moreover as TOW will continue to grow and earlier editions will continue to fade away, it'll be the only edition of Fantasy that counts in the eyes of the Fantasy playerbase at large.
In terms of tactical quality, 8th edition is better. In terms of popularity, AoS has the edge over TOW. So no matter how you approach the topic, you are beaten on both fronts.
As for 8th fading into oblivion, 6th edition hasn't. People still love that game. TOW's future is still uncertain. It could very well thrive and become a flagship game or remain a side game or even possibly dwindle and be axed by GW. Not to mention,
if the Femstodes are a sign of things to come, TOW could get wokified (admittedly unlikely, but possible). You of all people, who (rightfully) enjoys earlier editions of 40k over the current one, should not be so quick to discard 8th into the rubbish bin of wargaming.
Besides, my TOW/WHFB/AoS rebuttal ("
Maybe in terms of TOW, but definitely not in WHFB or AoS."), was not an instigation of a game versus game debate (not that I'd shy away from such a contest). I was simply stating facts:
- WHFB: Dark Elves > Beastmen (Dark Elves got a new book + models and were competitive. Beastmen were left with their 7th edition book and were a bottom basement army)
- AoS: DoK > Beastmen (Beastmen have recently gotten the axe. DoK remain a fully fledged army in the game)
- TOW: Dark Elves < Beastmen (Beastmen are a featured faction, while the Dark Elves aren't)
You can't be everything at once you know
Please do not project your mortal limitations upon me.

I am as far above gods as they are above you.
I see no pro-painted Archaon model in your army. You can't possibly be the Everchosen unless you actually have a model of him in your army

.
I do have an Archaon model (two actually, one mounted and the ultra rare unmounted variant).
As for it being pro-painted, I'm not about to pay someone to paint my models. I'd rather have them sprue grey (or in this case pewter silver).
What would you think if I tried to smear your Warriors of Chaos list building thread with anti-WoC posts?
I guess we'd have to engage in posting war... may the odds be ever in your favour.
Besides, if you hadn't made a retort in reference to my original post (which was on topic and relevant to the discussion at hand) I would have moved on by now. Just because my comment was in opposition to your own, does not mean that it does not have a place on the thread. The discussion revolved around which army should be kept, you thought it should be Beastmen and I felt it should be DoK ("Witch Elves"). If your opinion is a valid contribution to the thread, then so is mine. No?