Slann
NIGHTBRINGER
Second Spawning
- Messages
- 90,141
- Likes Received
- 277,820
- Trophy Points
- 113
I both agree and disagree with you.You are correct, that LOTR have less tolerance for BS. I believe that woke is not the only danger. I believe if you took the wokeness out of Rings of Power, it would be still be bad.
I've seen a few videos dissect all the many flaws I would say at once one out of three or one out of four of the flaws are woke related. Bad dialogue, bad pacing, bad characterization, bad fight scene cinematography, bad costumes, hack reveals, and unclear stakes are all unwoke related.
I do agree that many of these woke projects would be bad even if you removed the woke (for the reasons you outlined). However, in nearly every case, woke projects suffer from "Bad dialogue, bad pacing, bad characterization, bad fight scene cinematography, bad costumes, hack reveals, and unclear stakes". So I disagree that these elements are uncoupled from the woke problem, because when you prioritize the message above all, everything else suffers. It is theoretically possible to have a woke film that is solid in every other way, but time and time again we see that woke creators are unable to write and direct compelling stories. Their priorities are elsewhere and genuinely don't seem as talented as people who rose to creative positions based solely on merit. As such, I think they are intertwined and difficult to separate.


