Slann
Killer Angel
Prophet of the Stars
- Messages
- 20,359
- Likes Received
- 41,535
- Trophy Points
- 113
Hello everybody.
Today I played a new game and my opponent has made me doubt about the two endless spells that we usually use with the Seraphons.
When I read the descripción of Balewind Vortex, It says: " A Wizard on a Balewind Vortex can attempt to cast an additional spell in each of their hero phase"
I have played with Slann, and in my first turn I casted right BV spell and Cogs spell. Them, in my second turn, when I was going to change my 5 spells for 15 CCPs he said: "You can't do that. Your Slann Just knows 3 spells, so you just can change 3 spell for 9 CPPs"
He said that bases on the Next sentence written in the general handbook: "In your hero phase before attempting to Cast a spell with a Slann general, you can say that it Will Carry out CP intead"
So, If my Slann Just knows 3 spells I Just can "attempting to Cast" 3 spells.
Is he right?
(Sorry again for my English)
@The17thYak is right.
as explicitly stated by the rules for endless spells, when you buy (with points) an endless spell, each wizard in your army knows it, so with 2 ES, the Slann knows both of them, going to 5 spell known. Plus, the slann now knows also one additional spell from our lore, for a total (in this case) of 6 spell known.
ad if you play in a realm (you should), you know also additional spell from that realm.
Vortex and Cogs let you cast an extra spell. You gain 3 CCP by renouncing to a casting attemp, so you forego the extra attempts of casting and gain CCP for that. That's how the rules work.
the only vaguely plausible objection would be "in matched play you cannot cast twice the same endless spell, so even if your Slann knows Vortex, that spell cannot be cast, so you cannot renounce to cast a spell you cannot cast"
but rules don't work that way. You skip the attempt to cast a spell and accumulate CCP, so the spell wasn't even attempted. You don't have to declare what spell you forego… but you could forego each time "arcane bolt", cause a spell can be cast or attempted to cast only once, but you renounce to the attempt.
Seriously, AoS got many unclear rules, but this one is not one of those
Last edited: