Crazy to think about that our book has been out for almost half a year already. Covid has certainly put a stop to many games, but many of us have still played either on TTS or physical games in countries where there havent been hard lockdowns.
Im curious what kind of lists you guys are running with now and if they have changed a lot since the initial wave of ideas thrown around right after release. Also if any units etc. have surprised you positively on the table despite initially not looking too hot on paper.
I will admit I was hard-focused on the mathhammer side of things initially, but after having played a fair bit it seems like we have so much damage/MW output that filling your list with maximum damage units is insignificant, and that it is much more important to look at how the different units apply this damage (range etc).
I've been playing a ton of games on TTS and these two lists were the ones i found to be the "best" based on the people/meta i've been playing against.
Fangs of Sotek
Kroak general
Astrolith
Starpriest w/ hands of glory
Priest
40 skinks
40 skinks
5 guard
3 Sallies
3 Sallies
Balewind
Extra CP
Koatl's Claw
Kroak
Astrolith
Starpriest w/ harmony
Starseer w/ hands of glory
Oldblood Carno General w/ eviscerating Blade
Scarvet Carno w/ blade of realities
10 knights
10 knights
5 knights
10 skinks
Firelance
Balewind
Bound Geminids
I went from fangs to the koatl's list, and I enjoy the koatl's claw list a lot more. I found starborne shooting was just making me a lazy player. I think ultimately Fangs is probably the better list, but I think the book is just so strong top to bottom there's a strong list in any subfaction.
What I've found most surprising is just the sheer damage output/number of threats the book can put on the table. In the Koatl's claw list (for example) any of the knight units, kroak, or either of the carnos are all something that needs to be dealt with and thats just excessive for a lot of armies.
I've really, really not liked terradons when i've used them. I've found them to simply be far too unreliable from an output standpoint, and so much of the book is fast i haven't found i ever really needed something that moved 16''. 100% sure its just me, but yeah.
Only army i've really had any trouble with is Tzeentch, but even then its been super competitive every time. I honestly couldn't be happier with the book and have been having an absolute blast putting the army through its paces.
I do think people will be extremely surprised at what the meta is evolving to whenever restrictions start to lift, at least in the states.