Slann
Lord Agragax of Lunaxoatl
Eleventh Spawning
- Messages
- 9,757
- Likes Received
- 21,438
- Trophy Points
- 113
The only truly major issue they have is that they make the timeline weird. Somehow the galaxy goes from being ruled by the Republic, with it's jedi who help police it and resolve conflicts, to noone knowing what a jedi is over the course of 15-20 years. Don't get me wrong, the jedi are near mythical, and the average person definitly won't believe they have magical powers. But the knowledge that there's some weird sect of monks who say they have mystical powers and whom for some inexplicable reason are extremely influential in the goverment and get send out on important special diplomatic missions and what not shouldn't have dissappeared that quickly.
19 years (the established time period between Episodes III and IV) is actually a pretty long time to be honest, and as soon as Palpatine became Emperor all Jedi influence in the Senate was eradicated. He sent out troops to hunt down and murder anyone who ever had knowledge of Jedi lore, and 19 years is a long time to be hunted. Only especially skilled Jedi like Obi-Wan and Yoda could ever have survived such a long-running period on the run. I think it simply became a case that by that time, there were so few actually accurate sources of the Jedi's existence (they had pretty much all been either murdered by Palpatine's forces or press-ganged into his forces so they couldn't divulge their secrets) that the majority of the galaxy who remained alive started to wonder if they ever existed at all.
I mean yeah, midichlorians are stupid and all, but they're mentioned in what, 2 scenes? Just ignore em.
To be honest I actually prefer the concept of Midichlorians to the wishy-washy 'energy field that binds all things' nonsense, because it helps to ground the franchise into science fiction proper. I don't like the 'space fantasy' gimmick that they tried to make the Original Trilogy adhere to back in the 70s because it adds to the Flash Gordon campness that the OT already exudes.
Not a high bar to pass![]()
Still better being that low bar!

