Poll: Ice Cream Battle Royal!

[NIGHTBRINGER]

 

[NIGHTBRINGER]

My choices:

1. Coffee (easily the undisputed champion)
2. Cookie Dough
3. Peanut Butter Cup (peanut butter chocolate is pretty comparable though)

As for the best type of ice cream... GELATO!

 

[Fxt]

As an Italian I am offended by the lack of stracciatella among the voting choices
also missing the smurf flavor.
(i'm joking XD)


anyway i usually go for an Ice cream with 2-3 flavors of choccolate or a single big cone of super refreshing lemon

 

[Killer Angel]

As an Italian I am offended by the lack of stracciatella among the voting choices

I feel you.

Anyway, with the choices presented here, it's B and K, chocolate and coffee.
I just refuse to give a third option because there are flavors that to me are superior to the ones presented here.

 

[Imrahil]

My go to flavor most of the times is Pistachio, next is Coffee or Mokka, I also like a chocolate, but that includes Brownie or a triple chocolate. To pick one of the chocolate versions presented doesn't represent it in a good way.
Other flavor I like from time to time is Cookie Dough.

Grrr, !mrahil

 

[NIGHTBRINGER]

s an Italian I am offended by the lack of stracciatella among the voting choices

I feel you.

To pick one of the chocolate versions presented doesn't represent it in a good way.

The list of options is admittedly limited. If some variant of Hazelnut and/or Nutella was included, it would have snuck its way into my top three.

 

[Tk'ya'pyk]

Strawberry, Mint Chip, and Peanut Butter Cup, but there are other flavors - too many to really mention. Blueberry Cheesecake Chunk comes to mind. I don't like Pistachio or Coffee (never really developed a taste for coffee for some reason), but I would happily eat any of the others or any of a large number of flavors NOT on the list.

 

[Mrs. NIGHTBRINGER]

PB and Chocolate is always the best combo.

Cookie dough and Mint Chip would be my next choices.

 

[Just A Skink]

Vanilla, Chocolate, Oreo or Peanut Butter Chocolate.

 

[Scalenex]

Note, if I was visiting a friends house and my friend said "we have _____ ice cream in the freezer, would you like some?" I would say "Yes, thank you!" for any of these flavors.

If I was at an ice cream shop and about to pay my own money, then I suddenly become a lot more prejudiced.

I would never use my own money to buy cotton candy, coffee or birthday cake. I only bought pistachio once. It wasn't bad, but in my experience, people who like pistachio REALLY like pistachio so they oversold it for me, so I was mildly disappointed.

If I want ice cream, I want a sundae, root beer float or pie ala mode. Does this mean I like vanilla best? I certainly eat more vanilla in a typical year. I wouldn't want a scoop of vanilla by itself.

Mint chocolate chip and cookie dough were my favorite flavors as a kid. And if I'm going to eat a scoop of ice cream, I still have a tendency to lean towards these two flavors.

 

[Scalenex]

I was curious about butter brickle and used the internet to find out it's NOT the same as butter pecan. Which I guess I suspected because they taste similar but off.

Butter brickle is butter pecan with toffee pieces instead of pecans.

My dad was fond of butter brickle, but I don't see it available in a lot of places. I like it too. It's not in my top three I think it squeezes into my top five.

 

[NIGHTBRINGER]

I would never use my own money to buy cotton candy, coffee or birthday cake.

I'll agree with you on 2 out of those 3.

 

[Krox_v.2]

Peanut butter cup, Chocolate peanut butter and Strawberry. The flavor combination of chocolate and peanut butter is one of my favorites, sweets wise. Strawberry has always been a close second though.